May 16 23
A brief thought on A.I. as regards art.
Some preliminary notions, that is, before offering any thoughts, agreement needs to be attempted. Obviously, we are not saying that one should agree with any of the following, rather, it is just how we are exploring/thinking-about such things:
All is nature. That is, humans are nature. Humans do not stand outside the processes of this world in some sort of special circumstance. Humans are subject to all the same forces as everything else — ever-changing as they may be.
Evolution is likely the best way to describe this process of response and perpetuation. Evolution being the continual and constant mutation and adaptation life forms undergo as they try to stay cohesive and consistent across generations and iterations, as they meet all manner of novelty. (More often than not, such changes are barely perceptible at scale). We don’t claim to understand the breadth or complexity of such transcendental processes, or where any of these local/cosmic, exterior/interior impulses come from — nor do we think of these processes as anything like linear…
Part of this evolutionary procession is humanity’s increased mental capacities/abilities (over many millennia) to make more and more complex tools (in the spirit of stabilization for the species). But with all omni-directional increase comes the need for a counter weight; for the “intelligence” to stay focused on toolmaking, there needs to be equal thought ballast— so that the “intelligence” (this high analytical ability) doesn’t dangerously turn inward on itself. This mental ballast could be called our psychological system.
The notion that this pushes (like why we are taking pains to mention it) is that our reading of the world is specific, that is anthropocentric. Our minds don’t have access to the world, but rather interpret it. We live in an anthropomorphically symbolic dimension.
So, keeping the above in mind. We should never be convinced that what is at hand (perceptually or conceptually) constitutes an understanding of the actual Situation.
Art is not an indelible truth that we discover but a process of self/situational engagement to assist in adaptation and thriving, to our ever changing, primarily unpredictable / unknowable environments.
Specifically, art is an idea (a theory, an emotion, etc.) being interpretated, translated or grounded into a medium (paint, dance, words, film, or the like). This is not a mathematical process but one that involves ambiguity and imagination. So as said above, Art is likely one of the fundamental processes of testing — Art in this light could be considered as a technique in the same class as our immune system, just cognitive.
So, the idea that AI could design or do art, to us, is silly or over-serious. It is simply a tool, like a paintbrush or a nuclear bomb.
Art and design are processes of learning/improving not of achievement. Ease is pointless with art, struggle is the thing.
As a final thought we find AI concerns curious in general — like previous alarmist notions of the singularity — every night we are compelled to sleep, every day we are compelled to eat. What do we actually know about the language of trees or the language of the breeze that blows through the tree’s leaves? Very little.
Some preliminary notions, that is, before offering any thoughts, agreement needs to be attempted. Obviously, we are not saying that one should agree with any of the following, rather, it is just how we are exploring/thinking-about such things:
All is nature. That is, humans are nature. Humans do not stand outside the processes of this world in some sort of special circumstance. Humans are subject to all the same forces as everything else — ever-changing as they may be.
Evolution is likely the best way to describe this process of response and perpetuation. Evolution being the continual and constant mutation and adaptation life forms undergo as they try to stay cohesive and consistent across generations and iterations, as they meet all manner of novelty. (More often than not, such changes are barely perceptible at scale). We don’t claim to understand the breadth or complexity of such transcendental processes, or where any of these local/cosmic, exterior/interior impulses come from — nor do we think of these processes as anything like linear…
Part of this evolutionary procession is humanity’s increased mental capacities/abilities (over many millennia) to make more and more complex tools (in the spirit of stabilization for the species). But with all omni-directional increase comes the need for a counter weight; for the “intelligence” to stay focused on toolmaking, there needs to be equal thought ballast— so that the “intelligence” (this high analytical ability) doesn’t dangerously turn inward on itself. This mental ballast could be called our psychological system.
The notion that this pushes (like why we are taking pains to mention it) is that our reading of the world is specific, that is anthropocentric. Our minds don’t have access to the world, but rather interpret it. We live in an anthropomorphically symbolic dimension.
So, keeping the above in mind. We should never be convinced that what is at hand (perceptually or conceptually) constitutes an understanding of the actual Situation.
Art is not an indelible truth that we discover but a process of self/situational engagement to assist in adaptation and thriving, to our ever changing, primarily unpredictable / unknowable environments.
Specifically, art is an idea (a theory, an emotion, etc.) being interpretated, translated or grounded into a medium (paint, dance, words, film, or the like). This is not a mathematical process but one that involves ambiguity and imagination. So as said above, Art is likely one of the fundamental processes of testing — Art in this light could be considered as a technique in the same class as our immune system, just cognitive.
So, the idea that AI could design or do art, to us, is silly or over-serious. It is simply a tool, like a paintbrush or a nuclear bomb.
Art and design are processes of learning/improving not of achievement. Ease is pointless with art, struggle is the thing.
As a final thought we find AI concerns curious in general — like previous alarmist notions of the singularity — every night we are compelled to sleep, every day we are compelled to eat. What do we actually know about the language of trees or the language of the breeze that blows through the tree’s leaves? Very little.